All rural areas have fewer doctors per 1,000 residents when compared to urban areas, a report by the Association of French rural mayors (AMRF) shows. Many also have twice as few specialists as the cities. We look at which rural areas are most affected by this.
Rural mayors have raised the alert over France’s lack of medical cover in countryside areas for many years, publishing annual reports on different aspects of the issue.
While the causes of France’s unequal distribution of doctors are rooted in the country’s healthcare system, economic structure and geography - and beyond the scope of the AMRF studies - the effects of the disparity are clear.
A 2021 AMFR report, using 2020 data, shows that people in rural areas:
Consume 20% less medical care than those in urban areas (all ages combined)
Have 31% less access to chemotherapy and dialysis
Have two years less life expectancy than those in urban areas
Have fewer doctors per 1,000 inhabitants, half of whom are older than 55
Have seen the number of doctors per 1,000 inhabitants fall in 80% of rural areas between 2010 and 2017
Density of GPs in France
Pic: AMRF
The data confirms that Paris and Marseille (Bouches-du Rhône) have significantly higher concentrations of GPs per 1,000 inhabitants. The national average is taken as 1.33 GPs per 1,000 inhabitants.
However, while not as high as in the cities, there are also relatively high concentrations in:
Haute-Vienne
Pyrénées-Orientales
Alpes-de-Haute-Provence
Hautes-Alpes
The departments with the lowest density of GPs per 1,000 are:
Ad
Ain
Yonne
Loiret
Seine-et-Marne
Eure-et-Loire
Essonne
Eure
Val-d’Oise
Oise
Sarthes
Mayenne
Density of specialist doctors in France
Pic: AMRF
The AMFR’s data for specialist doctors, such as paediatricians, dermatologists, psychiatrists or anaesthetists, shows an even greater disparity between the major cities Paris, Marseille (Bouches-du-Rhône), Toulouse, (Haute-Garonne), Lyon (Rhône) and Bordeaux (Gironde) and the rest of France.
The national average is taken as 1.9 specialists per 1,000 inhabitants.
Other departments with high concentrations of specialist doctors are
Alpes Maritimes
Hérault
Pyrénées-Atlantiques
Territoire de Belfort
Bas-Rhin
However, of the many areas that fall behind, the worst served for specialists are:
Eure
Orne
Deux Sevres
Indre
Lot
Jura
Haute-Saône
Which rural departments are the best and worst served for medical care?
The AMFR’s data show a significant north-south divide on medical care.
The Paca region fares well for both GPs and specialists, however in more rural areas such as Alpes-de-Haute-Provence and Hautes-Alpes specialist care is lacking.
Conversely, the Normandy region and Eure in particular fare badly, placed far below the national averages by the AMFR study.
